New: Test GTM Assistant free on your development store.

Blog

Switching tracking apps? List your tags first

Updated

List your tags before you switch

Short answer: before you switch tracking apps or setups on Shopify, list every tag your store runs, including old Google Tag Manager containers and remarketing tags. After the switch, confirm each one still works or was replaced on purpose. In one case we reviewed, a remarketing tag left behind stopped working, and nobody noticed for about four months.

Switching your tracking setup is usually done for good reasons: better data, fewer apps, one sender for each platform. The new setup gets tested carefully. What gets forgotten is everything the old one was quietly doing.

What can go wrong when you switch?

In one case we reviewed (the store isn't named), a Google Ads remarketing tag lived in an old Google Tag Manager container. When the store's tracking changed, that tag stopped working. Nothing broke visibly: orders kept coming, conversions kept arriving. But the remarketing lists slowly emptied, and nobody noticed for about four months.

That's the pattern. Conversion tracking gets checked after a switch, because everyone looks at sales. Tags that do other jobs, such as building audiences, linking ad clicks or feeding a tool nobody opens every day, can stop without anyone looking.

Which tags do stores forget?

Tag What it does What happens if it stops
Remarketing tag (Google Ads, Meta and others) Builds the audiences you show ads to again Remarketing lists empty slowly; campaigns weaken
Conversion linker Helps Google Ads connect a sale to the ad click Fewer conversions credited to your ads
Old pixels from earlier apps Sent events from a tool you replaced Either nothing, or the same sale counted twice
Tags in an old Tag Manager container Anything someone added years ago Whatever they did stops, often unseen
Partner and affiliate tags Credit sales to partners Partners stop being paid correctly

How do you list your tags before switching?

  1. Check your apps. Note every app that sends tracking data and what it sends.
  2. Check Shopify's customer events. Look at the pixels listed there.
  3. Check your theme. Look for scripts added directly to the theme.
  4. Check every Google Tag Manager container the store has ever used, not only the current one.
  5. Write it down. For each tag: what it sends, to which platform, and who relies on it.

How do you check after the switch?

  • Go down your list. For each tag, confirm it still works, or that its job moved to the new setup on purpose.
  • Use each platform's own checks. For example, Google Ads tag diagnostics show whether a tag is firing.
  • Compare before and after. Conversions, audience sizes and partner sales should look the same a week after the switch as a week before, unless you meant to change them.

How does GTM Assistant help?

GTM Assistant sends each sale server-side, directly to your platforms, with one sender for each platform. Every GTM Assistant plan starts with a review of your current tracking. You confirm the findings before we change anything. After setup we compare against the snapshot we took before, so you can see that everything you relied on still works.

Install GTM Assistant from the Shopify App Store

Frequently asked questions

What can break when I switch tracking apps?
Anything the old setup carried that the new one doesn't: remarketing tags, the conversion linker, old pixels, or tags in an old Google Tag Manager container. They can stop without any error.

How do I list the tags on my Shopify store?
Check your apps, your theme, Shopify's customer events (pixels), and any Google Tag Manager containers, and write down what each tag sends and to which platform.

How do I know a tag still works after the switch?
Use each platform's own check, for example Google Ads tag diagnostics, and compare the numbers the platform received before and after the switch.

Does GTM Assistant check my existing tags?
Yes. Every GTM Assistant plan starts with a review of your current tracking, and you confirm the findings before we change anything.

Sources

Related: Is your tracking broken? The silent failures nobody notices · Server-side tracking explained for Shopify merchants

Not sure what your store is running?

Our free tracking audit compares the orders and revenue Shopify recorded with what GA4 and Google Ads received, and flags duplicate purchases. We reply within 24 hours. The report takes up to one week.

Get your free tracking audit

Keep reading